Torts and Retribution

‘Brimming with comparativist insights, Torts and Retribution should be read by legal scholars and practitioners throughout the world. The book deepens our theoretical conception of punitive damages and, in the process, expands our understanding of tort law itself.’ Douglas A. Kysar, Joseph M. Field ’55 Professor of Law, Yale University

‘An original and lucid contribution to the fields of torts and private law, Torts and Retribution deploys erudition from across the Atlantic world to offer a powerful answer to a longstanding conundrum. None of our existing paradigms adequately explains the persistence of punitive damages. But María Guadalupe Martínez Alles now bids to supply the best answer in years. Ranging from moral theory and private law doctrine to consumer protection in the mass marketplace, this book is an instant classic.’ John Fabian Witt, Allen H. Duffy Class of 1960 Professor of Law, Yale University

‘Torts and Retribution stands on its head the belief that punitive damages are an anomalous intrusion of criminal law concerns into a legal field whose role is to repair, not to punish. Integrating insights from philosophy and psychology with lay intuition, Torts and Retribution argues that punitive damages paid by egregious wrongdoers to those they have wronged are a fitting response to serious mistreatment. Without them, the law of torts would be a less complete institution. This deeply thoughtful and persuasive book will change the way that anyone interested in torts thinks about the field.’ Gregory Keating, William T. Dalessi Professor of Law and Philosophy, USC Gould School of Law

‘In this bold and humane reparative work, María Guadalupe Martínez Alles envisions the remedy of cash damages as attentive to the significance of the wrong that injured a plaintiff. Torts and Retribution: The Case for Punitive Damages elegantly locates compassion, dignity, and justice in the punishment that private law can deliver.’ Anita Bernstein, Anita and Stuart Subotnick Professor of Law, Brooklyn Law School

‘No better book has been written to challenge conventional thinking about the boundary between criminal law and tort. Specialists in both fields will be required to rethink their preconceptions.’ Douglas Husak, Distinguished Professor of Philosophy (Emeritus), Rutgers University

‘Martínez Alles has produced a valuable book examining the important question of the best way to understand what retribution is, and what tort law might need it for. Her relational retribution highlights the victim of a tort in a novel way and is a useful contribution to debates held in many legal systems, most obviously to common law punitive damages, but more widely to things like ‘civil fines’ and ‘civil punitive sanctions’ found in civilian systems.’ Matthew Dyson, Professor of Civil and Criminal Law, University of Oxford